Palumbo’S Pizza Reviews, Ratings & Menu

General Info

At Palumbo’S Pizza, located at 246 N Courtland St, East Stroudsburg, PA 18301, United States, the atmosphere feels exactly how a neighborhood pizza restaurant should-casual, welcoming, and focused on great food. Walking in, the smell of freshly baked dough and melted cheese immediately sets the mood. It’s the kind of place locals return to often, not just because of the menu, but because the overall experience feels comfortable and familiar.

The menu at Palumbo’S Pizza is centered around classic pizza shop favorites, but a few standout dishes quickly catch attention. One item that regulars often talk about in their reviews is the Pizza Fries. Served hot and loaded with pizza-style toppings, they combine crispy fries with rich sauce and melted cheese, creating something that feels both indulgent and satisfying. It’s a simple idea, yet when done right, it becomes a dish you remember long after the meal.

Another popular option on the menu is the Stromboli. This dish arrives golden and freshly baked, with the dough perfectly crisp on the outside and soft inside. Each bite delivers a balance of savory fillings wrapped in warm dough, making it a reliable choice whether you’re dining in or grabbing takeout. Many visitors mention that the Stromboli pairs perfectly with other items from the menu, making it easy to share at the table.

The restaurant itself is designed for convenience. Guests can enjoy onsite services, which makes dining in relaxed and easy for families, friends, or anyone stopping by after a long day. Payments are straightforward as well, since the restaurant accepts NFC mobile payments and credit cards, giving customers flexibility at checkout.

Parking is another detail that adds to the overall comfort of visiting this location. Palumbo’S Pizza offers a free parking lot, along with additional parking nearby, so visitors don’t need to worry about finding a space before enjoying their meal. This small convenience makes a noticeable difference, especially during busy dining hours.

Spending time here feels like discovering a local favorite that has quietly built a strong reputation. Reviews from visitors often highlight not just the food but the laid-back vibe that keeps people coming back. Whether someone is exploring pizza spots around East Stroudsburg or simply searching for a reliable restaurant with a satisfying menu, Palumbo’S Pizza delivers a straightforward, enjoyable dining experience right in the neighborhood.

What customers say?

“ Everything about this place is great! The employees are kind and thoughtful, the place is clean, and most importantly their pizza is absolute perfection! I love their cicilian pizza, and their garlic knots are to die for! The sauce is on point too! I used to live in NY so my expectations for pizza is pretty high, but this place more than exceeds my expectations. 100/10 recommend, and a million stars ⭐ ”

- Raquel Uberti -

“ I recently had the pleasure of dining at Palumbo's Italian Pizza, and I can't help but share my extraordinary experience. If you're in search of the quintessential New York City pizza, this is as close as you're going to get. From the moment I walked in, it was evident that Palumbo's takes immense pride in their culinary craft. Everything, including the pizza, is made fresh daily, and you can literally witness their commitment to freshness. I had the pleasure of watching them in action, especially their commendable practice of giving any leftover food to their employees at the end of the day, which speaks volumes about their values. For my meal, I ordered a large pizza pie, and I couldn't resist a special order of their sausage roll. To say it was enormous is an understatement; this sausage roll could easily feed a small party! What truly impressed me was how perfectly the sausage, cheese, and peppers were distributed throughout every section of the roll. It's a true flavor explosion, and the combination of a crunchy, yet soft crust was simply heavenly. The best part? The generous portions ensured that I had some left for my breakfast the next day. Yummy, indeed! Apart from the delectable food, the staff at Palumbo's are warm, welcoming, and incredibly inviting. They make you feel like family from the moment you walk in. The restaurant itself is well-organized and impeccably maintained, adding to the overall pleasant dining experience. Palumbo's Italian Pizza has easily become my go-to pizza joint in the area. If you're a pizza lover or a fan of Italian cuisine, I highly recommend giving Palumbo's a try. You won't be disappointed, and like me, you might just find yourself coming back for more. ”

- noemi mirra -

“ Customer service was impeccable, pizza always great . Always served a wonderful smile ! ”

- Kimberley Kimmy Kim -